Thriller vs horror: Understanding the differences
When we settle in for a movie night, picking between a thriller and a horror film can sometimes feel like a coin toss. After all, both genres promise to spike our adrenaline and keep us glued to the screen.
But what exactly makes a thriller different from a horror movie? And why does knowing the difference matter to us, the audience?
At their core, thriller and horror films are about giving us a good scare, but they do it in different ways.
A thriller is like a puzzle, full of twists and turns that keep us guessing until the last moment. It’s about suspense — making us hold our breath as we wait to see what happens next.
A horror movie seeks to confront us with our deepest fears, often through supernatural elements or shocking imagery designed to horrify and disturb.
A thriller might leave us feeling exhilarated after a tense ride, while a horror film might leave us with a lingering sense of unease. By recognizing what sets these genres apart, we can better choose our next movie based on the kind of experience we’re in the mood for.
Defining the horror vs thriller genres
What is horror?
When we talk about horror movies, we’re talking about a genre that is designed to stir up our deepest fears. These films aim to evoke strong feelings of fear, shock — and sometimes even disgust. But how do they manage to get such intense reactions from us?
Horror movies often use scary elements like ghosts, monsters, or other supernatural beings to create a sense of dread. They might also include scenes that are quite graphic, showing things that can make us feel uncomfortable or scared.
The idea is to confront us with scenarios we hope never to face in real life, such as being chased by a villain or experiencing a haunted house.
The goal of a horror film is not just to scare us for the moment but to leave a lasting impression. They play on our basic human fears and test how we react to the unknown or the dangerous.
By watching these movies, we get to experience fear in a safe environment, which is part of the thrill. The best horror films are those that can make us jump out of our seats or stay with us long after we’ve finished watching, making us think twice before turning off the light at night.
Horror taps into our primal instincts. Whether it’s through a ghost story or a tale of survival against all odds, it’s about exploring those dark corners of our imagination that we usually keep hidden.
What is a thriller?
A thriller movie is like a roller coaster ride that doesn’t need to leave the ground. These films are all about creating suspense, excitement, and anticipation, keeping us on the edge of our seats from start to finish.
But what sets thrillers apart from horror films?
Thrillers focus on the suspense aspect more than anything else. They involve complex stories full of twists and turns, where the outcome is uncertain until the very end.
The tension in these movies builds slowly, making us guess what will happen next and often surprising us with unexpected outcomes.
The characters in thrillers are usually trying to solve a mystery, escape a dangerous situation, or sometimes even stop a villain. The excitement comes from trying to piece together the puzzle before the characters do, or wondering how they’ll escape a dangerous situation.
While thrillers can also make our hearts race, the fear they evoke is more about the anticipation of danger than the horror of facing it.
Another key element of thrillers is the psychological aspect. These movies often explore the minds of their characters, exploring what makes them tick and how they react under extreme stress. This can add a layer of depth to the story that’s even more engaging for us as viewers.
Thrillers are about giving us a suspenseful experience, making us think and keeping us guessing. Be it a spy adventure, a crime drama, or a psychological thriller, these films promise to keep our hearts racing and our minds engaged.
Iconic Horror Films
The Exorcist (1973)
The Exorcist is a film that truly embodies the essence of the horror genre, using supernatural elements to evoke fear in its audience.
It tells the terrifying story of a young girl named Regan who becomes possessed by a demonic entity. The film follows her mother’s desperate attempt to save her through the help of two priests who perform an exorcism.
What makes The Exorcist stand out as a horror classic is its use of supernatural themes to tap into our primal fears. The idea of possession — of losing control to an unseen, malevolent force — strikes a chord with our deepest anxieties about the unknown and the unseen.
The film’s realistic portrayal of Regan’s transformation and the ensuing battle to save her soul is both disturbing and compelling, making it a classic example of how horror films use supernatural elements to create a sense of dread.
The effectiveness of The Exorcist also lies in its ability to blend the supernatural with the all-too-real. The setting, a normal household, and the characters, a regular family, make the supernatural events that unfold all the more shocking.
The Shining (1980)
The Shining is another film that perfectly captures the essence of horror.
Based on the novel by Stephen King, it tells the story of Jack Torrance, who becomes the winter caretaker of the isolated Overlook Hotel along with his wife, Wendy, and son, Danny. What starts as a quiet retreat quickly turns into a nightmare as the hotel’s sinister secrets come to light.
Much like The Exorcist, one of the major elements that make The Shining a true horror film is its use of supernatural occurrences.
Danny possesses a psychic ability known as “The Shining,” which allows him to see the hotel’s horrific past. The hotel itself seems to have a life of its own, with ghostly apparitions and a malevolent force that drives Jack to madness.
The setting of the Overlook Hotel is crucial to the film’s horror atmosphere. Its vast, empty spaces and the isolation of being snowed in during the winter contribute to a growing sense of dread.
This feeling is amplified by Kubrick’s use of unsettling visuals and a haunting soundtrack, creating an environment where fear thrives. The film also explores the dangers of isolation and the fragility of the human mind, making us question what we would do in a similar situation.
Jack’s descent into madness is a central theme of The Shining. His transformation from a loving father to a homicidal maniac is both terrifying and tragic.
From the image of the twins in the hallway to the scene of Jack hacking through the bathroom door, the film is filled with moments that have become iconic in horror cinema.
Iconic thriller films
Seven (1995)
Seven is a film that defines the crime thriller genre, showcasing a mix of tension and psychological elements. The film’s climax (which I won’t spoil here) is designed to leave us with a lingering sense of unease.
It tells the story of two detectives who are on the trail of a serial killer. The killer’s crimes are inspired by the seven deadly sins, leading the detectives on a dark and twisting path to catch him.
What sets Seven apart as a thriller is its focus on the psychological battle between the detectives and the killer. The film explores the minds of its characters, showing us the toll that the investigation takes on them.
The tension builds slowly, starting with the discovery of each new, elaborately staged crime scene. With each sin, the stakes get higher, and the urgency to catch the killer grows.
This tension is not just about the fear of what the killer will do next — it’s also about the moral and ethical questions that the detectives face as they learn more about the case.
It’s almost as if the city itself is a character, contributing to the oppressive atmosphere and the sense of hopelessness that pervades the story.
North by Northwest (1959)
North by Northwest is a classic example of a thriller that expertly combines suspense with action, all without horror elements.
The film follows the story of Roger Thornhill, an advertising executive who gets mistaken for a government agent by foreign spies. This case of mistaken identity launches him into a dangerous cross-country adventure, trying to avoid capture while uncovering a conspiracy.
What makes North by Northwest stand out as a thriller is its mix of suspense, intrigue, and action. Hitchcock, known as the master of suspense, keeps us on the edge of our seats with a series of close calls, chases, and clever escapes.
From the iconic crop duster scene to the climactic chase across Mount Rushmore, the film is packed with moments that define the action-thriller genre.
Unlike horror movies, which aim to scare and disturb, North by Northwest thrives on the thrill of the chase and the satisfaction of puzzle-solving.
Roger Thornhill is a charming and relatable protagonist whose ordinary life is turned upside down, making us root for him all the more. His interactions with the mysterious Eve Kendall add an aspect of romance and intrigue to the story.
The suspense comes not from fear of the supernatural or the grotesque but from the excitement of the unknown and the dangers that the protagonist faces in his quest to clear his name.
Films that blur the line
Silence of the Lambs (1991)
Silence of the Lambs is an example of how a film can contain elements of both thriller and horror genres.
The movie follows young FBI trainee Clarice Starling as she seeks the help of imprisoned cannibalistic serial killer Hannibal Lecter to catch another serial killer known as Buffalo Bill.
The film’s thriller aspects are evident in its plot and structure, focusing on the investigation and the cat-and-mouse game between Clarice and Lecter. The suspense builds as Clarice goes deeper into the case, using her wit and instincts to unravel the clues that Lecter provides.
On the horror side, Silence of the Lambs does not shy away from depicting the macabre details of Buffalo Bill’s crimes and Lecter’s past. The film’s horror elements are not just in the acts of violence but in the psychological terror that Lecter exerts over Clarice and others.
Thanks to its dark visual style and haunting score, the movie is charged with tension. The performances, particularly Anthony Hopkins’ portrayal of Hannibal Lecter, add a frightening and unsettling intensity to the film’s atmosphere.
It’s a film that challenges us, scares us, and keeps us guessing until the very end.
Get Out (2017)
Get Out is another movie that brilliantly combines elements of both social thriller and horror.
The film tells the story of Chris, a young black man who visits his white girlfriend’s family estate and uncovers a disturbing secret about the seemingly friendly community.
What makes Get Out stand out is its ability to use the framework of a horror film to explore social themes, particularly racism and cultural appropriation.
The horror elements in this movie are not just for scares — they serve to amplify the real-world anxieties and tensions that the film seeks to address.
From the creepy atmosphere of the secluded estate to the chilling behavior of the people Chris encounters, the film uses horror to highlight the protagonist’s growing sense of unease and entrapment.
At the same time, Get Out functions as a thriller, keeping us on the edge of our seats as Chris unravels the mystery behind the family’s facade. The suspense builds as the true nature of the community’s intentions is revealed, leading to a thought-provoking climax.
Audience preferences between thriller vs horror
When it comes to picking between a horror vs thriller movie, everyone has their own favorite.
But have you ever wondered why some of us gravitate towards the heart-pounding fear of horror films, while others prefer the edge-of-your-seat suspense of thrillers? It turns out, our choices can say a lot about us and what we’re looking to get out of a movie experience.
People who love horror films might be thrill-seekers, looking to feel the adrenaline rush that comes from being scared in a safe environment. Horror movies provide a way to confront fears head-on, allowing viewers to experience intense emotions without the real-world risks.
This can be a form of escapism or a way to test one’s own limits of fear and disgust from the comfort of their own home.
Fans of thrillers might be drawn to the mental challenge these films offer. Thrillers often involve complex plots and require viewers to pay close attention to details, making predictions about what will happen next.
Psychologically, the preference for horror versus thrillers can also reflect how individuals cope with anxiety and stress. Watching horror films can be a way to release pent-up emotions, allowing viewers to confront their fears in a controlled setting.
Thrillers, with their focus on suspense and anticipation, might appeal to those who enjoy the tension but prefer a narrative that feels more grounded in reality, without the supernatural or grotesque elements typical of horror.
Personal taste plays a significant role as well. Some people have a higher tolerance for the graphic content often found in horror films, while others might find the psychological tension of thrillers more appealing.
Our past experiences, cultural background, and even our mood at the time can all influence our choice between horror and thriller.
Thriller vs horror: How to choose what to watch
Deciding whether to watch a horror film or a thriller can be tricky. Both genres offer exciting experiences but cater to different moods and preferences.
Consider your mood: Are you looking for a heart-racing scare that might have us sleeping with the lights on? If the idea of jumping at shadows and feeling the adrenaline rush sounds appealing, a horror film might be the way to go.
But if you’re more in the mood for a story that keeps you guessing, with complex characters and a plot that twists and turns, a thriller could be more satisfying.
Think about what you want to feel: If you’re eager to experience the depths of fear and confront supernatural or grotesque elements, horror is the clear choice. These films often push the boundaries of our comfort zones, challenging us to face our fears.
On the other hand, if you’re more interested in the thrill of the chase, solving a mystery, or unraveling a conspiracy without the horror elements, then a thriller would be a better fit.
Reflect on your tolerance for graphic content: Horror films often contain more graphic scenes, designed to shock and disturb.
If you’re not in the mood to handle graphic content or if it’s something that generally doesn’t sit well with you, then you might want to steer towards a thriller.
Consider the setting and atmosphere you’re in the mood for: Are you drawn to dark, ominous settings that set the stage for unspeakable horrors?
Or do you prefer real-world scenarios that could, in theory, happen to you? The former leans more towards horror, while the latter is typical of thrillers.
Decide if you’re in the mood for supernatural elements: If the idea of ghosts, demons, or unexplained phenomena excites you, then horror films are likely to satisfy that craving.
If you’re more interested in tales grounded in reality, where human actions and psychological depth take center stage, then a thriller would be more up your alley.
As you can see, both genres have their own appeal and have the ability to give us an engaging (and terrifying) viewing experience.
So, what are you in the mood for tonight — a scare that sends shivers down your spine or a suspenseful mystery that keeps you on the edge of your seat? 👻
DON’T MISS! 6 historical ghost ships surrounded by mystery
Share the scare!
If you’d like to share this post on Pinterest, please feel free to click save on the image below. And thank you for your support!
